Monday, May 20, 2013
Last Updated: 19 May 20:04 PM IST
6 December 2011
Press Trust of India
NEW DELHI, 6 DEC: Telecom minister Mr Kapil Sibal today vowed to stop offensive and defamatory content on Internet sites as a controversy raged over the government's move to monitor content in cyber space.
Maintaining that the government does not want to interfere with the freedom of the Press, he said if the social networking sites are not willing to cooperate with the government on stopping incendiary material “then it is the duty of the government to think of steps that we need.”
“This government does not believe in censorship and does not believe either directly or indirectly interefering in the freedom of the Press. We have demonstrated that time and again,” he said.
Mr Sibal's hurriedly-called Press conference came against the backdrop of the government's meetings with officials from Google, Microsoft, Facebook and Yahoo over the past few weeks after offensive material particularly against Congress leader Mrs Sonia Gandhi and Prime Minister Mr Manmohan Singh was put on the Net. He said his request for cooperation from them fell on “deaf ears” and “we will not allow intermediaries to say that we throw up our hands and we cannot do anything about it.”
Facebook, in its reaction, said it will cooperate in removing any content that violates its terms which are designed to keep material that is hateful, threatening, incites violence or contains nudity off the service.
Google said it will abide by the local law and take any material if it violates its policies but asserted that it will not remove any content just because it is controversial.
“We recognise the government's interest in minimising the amount of abusive content that is available online and will continue to engage with the Indian authorities as they debate this important issue,” the Facebook statement said.
Google said that when content is illegal it abides by the local law and removes it. And even where the content is legal but violates “our terms and conditions, we take that down too, once we have been notified.” However, it says, when content is legal and does not violate its policies, it will not remove just because it is controversial.
Even as Mr Sibal defended the government's move, criticism poured in the cyber space that India should not emulate countries like China in attempting to gag freedom of expression.
However, the minister got support from Mr Shashi Tharoor, Congress MP, who is popular in the cyber world. “Have to say I support Kapil Sibal on the examples he gave me: deeply offensive material about religions and communities that could incite riots,” Mr Tharoor tweeted.
But his political rivals and MPs Mr Varun Gandhi and Mr Jayant Choudhary differed. Mr Gandhi said Internet is the only truly democratic medium free of “vested interests, media owners and paid-off journos. Can see why Sibal wants to gag it,” he said.Mr Choudhary said “Censorship of the Internet - Forget the desirability issue for a minute, IS IT EVEN POSSIBLE??!!!”